Pros
Gorgeous, high-quality enameled cast iron
Durable with great size and shape for various dishes
Resistant to chipping and non-stick black interiors
Self-basting lids reduce cooking time
Versatile for smaller families
Excellent for acidic ingredients
Black interior doesn't stain and is easy to clean
Perfect for soups, stews, baking bread
Beautiful finish in multiple colors
Retains heat well and cooks evenly
Lasts a lifetime with proper care
Stable at high temperatures
Safe cookware option, no rust
Multiple sizes and charming figural pieces available
Cons
Handles are rough to touch
Very heavy, not easy to handle
Interiors are difficult to clean, not dishwasher safe
Main Product Advantages
10 Self-Basting Lid
The self-basting lid with moisture bumps is highly appreciated for its functionality, which reduces the need for constant stirring and helps to achieve better cooking results.
9 Durability
The Staub Cast Iron Dutch Oven is praised for its durability, with several reviews highlighting that it resists chipping and rusting, maintains its pristine condition for years, and can be passed down through generations.
9 Versatility in Cooking
The tall, slim profile of the cocotte is highlighted as being very versatile for different types of cooking, from making soups to baking bread. Its tall sides also help in reducing spatters.
9 Acidic Ingredient Resistance
Staub’s black ceramic lining is particularly noted for its imperviousness to prolonged exposure to acidic ingredients, making it ideal for recipes with citrus or other acidic components.
8 Enameled Finish
The product has a high-quality enameled finish that resists staining and is easy to clean. Some reviews mention the finish is more robust compared to other brands and retains its appearance over time.
8 Aesthetics
The product is often described as beautiful and available in several attractive colors, adding a touch of class to the kitchen.
7 Price
While generally considered pricey, many customers feel that the quality justifies the cost. It is sometimes available on sale, which improves its value for money.
6 Weight
The Dutch oven is heavy, which contributes to its durability and heat retention but can make it cumbersome to handle, clean, and store.
6 Cleaning
Cleaning is noted to be relatively easy compared to other enameled cast iron products, although it is not dishwasher safe and must be cleaned by hand.
5 Handles
While the handles are fully coated and sealed, they are described as rough by some users, which detracts from the overall experience. They require pot holders when handling during cooking due to their material.
STAUB Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5-qt Tall Cocotte Review
The 5-quart Tall Cocotte is a taller version of the classic 4-quart cocotte, making it the ideal tool for cooking larger quantities without taking up valuable stovetop space.
The additional height is especially useful in cooking bone-in meat cuts like crown roasts as well as layered dishes like tians, or dishes that rise, such as soufflés. Plus, the added height reduces the risk of liquids boiling over and reduces splatter when deep-frying or searing.
Like all STAUB cocottes, the Tall Cocotte is unsurpassed for slow-cooking meats and vegetables to tender perfection and for simmering hearty stews and soups. Cast iron possesses exceptional heat-retaining qualities, so the pot heats evenly throughout.
With a heavy weight, tight-fitting lid that retains moisture and tiny spikes on the lid interior that create a rain-forest effect evenly returning juices back onto food, you can expect moist, perfectly cooked food every time you use this pan.
Rooted in French culinary heritage, STAUB cookware is beloved by professional and home chefs for its exquisite craftsmanship, exceptional performance, and timeless beauty.
Each STAUB cocotte effortlessly and elegantly transitions from the oven to the table - you can cook and serve in the same dish. These heirloom pieces can be lovingly passed from generation to generation.
Conclusion
The STAUB Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5-qt Tall Cocotte is a versatile and efficient tool for any kitchen. Its added height offers practical advantages for various cooking needs, while its exceptional heat-retaining qualities and moisture-retentive lid ensure perfectly cooked meals. With its exquisite craftsmanship and elegant design, it is a valuable addition to both professional and home kitchens, promising to be a cherished heirloom for generations.
