Pros
Beautiful design
High-quality leather
Elegant slender shape
Good craftsmanship
Reputable brand
Cons
Difficult to put on and take off
No zipper or pull tabs
Inconsistent sizing
Main Product Advantages
9 Quality of Leather
Most reviewers highlight the high quality of the leather, noting it as soft, durable, and well-crafted. The craftsmanship received commendations across multiple reviews.
8 Design and Aesthetics
The Frye Melissa Button 2 boots are praised for their beautiful and elegant design, vintage leather, and antique metal hardware, giving them a classy equestrian-inspired look.
6 Fit for Purpose
While the boots are aesthetically pleasing and made for equestrian-inspired fashion, the practical usability is hindered by fit issues.
6 Consistency in Manufacturing
There are variations in fit and quality based on the manufacturing location (USA, Mexico, Italy, China), causing unpredictable size and fit issues for consumers.
5 Sizing and Fit
While some reviews mention accurate sizing, several others have issues with inconsistent sizing, making it challenging to find the right fit. The boots appear to run too big or too snug inconsistently.
5 Comfort
The boots face criticism regarding comfort, especially for people with high arches or wide calves. They're described as very tight, hard to get on and off, and uncomfortable for some users.
4 Ease of Use
A major complaint is the lack of a zipper or pull tabs, making the boots very difficult to put on and take off, which significantly affects user experience.
Product Review: Frye Melissa Button 2 Equestrian-Inspired Tall Boots for Women
The Frye Melissa Button 2 boots are crafted from high-quality Italian leather, offering an antiqued washed finish that gives them a timeless, vintage appeal. These knee-high boots feature a pull-on silhouette and a leather lining that adds to their luxurious feel and ensures comfort with every step.
Supportive and Flattering Design
The boots are contoured through the ankle, providing excellent support and a flattering shape for the wearer's legs. This design element not only enhances comfort but also adds to the stylish and elegant look of the boots.
Perfect Shaft Height
With a 15 ½” shaft height, these boots capture the essence of traditional English riding boots. This length is ideal for knee-high boots and ensures a perfect fit for most women, adding a touch of sophistication to any outfit.
Comfortable Circumference
The boots come with an 18 ½” shaft circumference, making them easy to pull on and off while providing a snug fit around the calf. This feature is particularly beneficial for those who seek both style and practicality in their footwear.
Slight Heel and Durable Outsole
Featuring a slight 1” heel and a strong leather outsole, these boots offer a balance of elegance and durability. The heel height is just right for adding a bit of lift without sacrificing comfort, making these boots suitable for everyday wear.
Conclusion
Overall, the Frye Melissa Button 2 Equestrian-Inspired Tall Boots for Women are a fantastic choice for those seeking a blend of style, comfort, and durability. Made from hard-wearing vintage leather with antique metal hardware, these boots are a timeless addition to any wardrobe. Whether you're searching for knee-high boots, leather riding boots, or simply a stylish pair of tall boots, these Frye boots are sure to meet your needs and exceed your expectations.
