Pros
Phenomenal follow-up to the original game
Engaging legacy mechanics with a story spanning decades
High replayability even after completing the core campaign
Intriguing overarching family storyline
Improved balance and gameplay over the original game
Addictive and immersive experience
Enhanced components and thematic atmosphere
Can be played in 'free play' mode after campaign
Cons
Balance issues and rule confusion from original game persist
Complex rules can be intimidating for new players
Requires careful handling of game components (don’t punch out all pieces immediately)
Main Product Advantages
10 Replayability
The modular tile system and the variety of haunts create a game where no two sessions are alike.
10 Story and Campaign
An overarching story spanning 14 games adds depth and continuity, with each action affecting future games, much like a TV season.
10 Fun Factor
Highly enjoyable, with players' favorite aspects being the evolving story and legacy elements.
9 Legacy Mechanics
Utilizes legacy components effectively, with permanent changes and evolving gameplay keeping the experience fresh and engaging.
9 Immersiveness
Atmospheric design and storyline elements enhance the immersive experience, with opportunities for role-playing.
8 Balancing
Significant improvements over the original game, with balanced haunts if rules are read thoroughly.
7 Component Quality
Mixed reviews on components. Some improvements like sturdier figures, but issues with detailed painting and sticker adherence.
6 Rule Complexity
Still complex with balance issues and vague rules requiring multiple references, which may scare away new players.
6 Learning Curve
Steep learning curve, and some ambiguity in rules necessitates house rules or online lookups.
5 Support and Packaging
Issues with damaged parts and poor support process, as well as poor initial packaging advice.
Introduction
The Avalon Hill Betrayal Legacy board game offers a unique gaming experience that combines the thrill of a legacy game with the excitement of the Betrayal series.
Gameplay
Betrayal Legacy takes players on a journey through a haunted house that builds and evolves over multiple sessions. Players encounter various scenarios that change the game’s story and mechanics. Each decision made impacts future games, making every playthrough unique and unpredictable.
Components
The game includes high-quality components such as detailed miniatures, sturdy tiles, and numerous cards that enhance the immersive experience. The artwork and thematic design elements are visually appealing and contribute to the eerie atmosphere of the game.
Replayability
With its legacy mechanics, the game offers high replay value as no two playthroughs are alike. The evolving narrative encourages players to come back and see how their choices have shaped the game world.
Accessibility
Although the game can be complex, the rulebook is well-written and provides clear instructions. First-time players may require a learning curve, but the engaging storyline and interactive elements make it worth the effort.
Conclusion
Avalon Hill Betrayal Legacy is a captivating board game that offers a rich, evolving narrative and high replayability. Its immersive components and engaging gameplay make it a standout choice for fans of legacy games and horror themes. While it may present a challenge to new players, the overall experience is both rewarding and memorable.
